March 2020 ATP Market Commentary: Gone Viral

• COVID-19 and its spread has meant significant market declines at unprecedented speeds
• Circumstances are markedly different from 2008 – the banking system is not the epicentre
• The pace of government responses, not to mention size, are extraordinary and necessary
• Approximately 35 days after full lockdown, China’s factories are fired once more
• Multi-generational investing opportunities are being created

INTRODUCTION

From the outset we just wanted to make mention of the fact that this must be the third iteration of the intended client updates. The pace of developments have meant each previous version, within a matter hours, seemed out of date – even just this weekend’s announcements from Germany brings reason to update our comments. Events are  unfolding at an unprecedented clip, however, as we touch on later, reassuringly, so has the wave upon wave of historical responses from central banks and governments globally. We’ve tried to adopt a punchier format than usual and organise the update under a question and answer format that we feel are most relevant to client circumstances.

WHERE HAVE WE COME FROM?

The outsized response from financial markets in some ways are reflective of a stock market that was seriously overextended and therefore highly vulnerable to a serious setback. In December going into late January, we saw overwhelming levels of bullishness in markets, spurred in part by ‘zero cost’ trading services available in the US, in a price war between the discount brokerages all looking to secure the custom of the American retail investors. Such overconfidence normally takes months to unwind, however, as we stand, that has been achieved in weeks rather than months. Now whilst many of the historical comparables we seek to draw on, in our asset allocation decision making seem to have lost
relevance in many cases, yet when considering the last 100 years of stock market history, we’re at a point which would suggest a higher probability of a multi month rebound in share prices. In short, whilst Covid-19 has ravaged financial markets, markets were susceptible to the degree they were on a sugar rush high but have reached levels that have previously seen rebounds.

The following table shows a number of circumstances where the US stock market (S&P 500), has lost 30% percent, and then shows the performance thereafter. Not every scenario sees share prices higher a year out, but many do.

1918 SEEMS A BETTER REFERENCE POINT THAN 2008

Coronavirus and the economic shock it is causing seems more relatable to the flu pandemic of 1918 rather than the Global Financial Crisis of 2008. The GFC was a balance sheet recession – it was caused by an overblown housing sector that collapsed, which led to a run on confidence on the banks.

Housing is the biggest single component of consumer wealth, and so the slowdown was so structural in nature that it needed a long drawn out recovery period. In contrast, it is not the banking system, (which is much better capitalised and resilient 12 years after the crisis), which is a weak point in the system – instead, on this occasion, it will be more be acutely felt in the travel, tourism and retail sectors. That’s not to say that the implications aren’t difficult to stomach – the global travel and tourism sector accounts for 10% of the global workforce. Airlines, cruise liners, hotels and restaurants and their supply chains will continue to be under significant pressure in the coming weeks – likely the summer at least before things normalise. Banks are better capitalised than they were in 2008, they present less credit risk, the epicentre of this particular difficulty in elsewhere. Moreover, should the size and speed of government and fiscal responses continue to build unabated, we hope that this will reflect a severe, yet shorter tailed cyclical slowdown rather than the structural recession which played out in 2008.

Given the current circumstances, its understandable that markets do not turn around on a sixpence, but we should expect some response ultimately, given nearly 40bn USD per month is now being injected into the system in what is in effect QE4. In fact, that’s just in the US. Previously when QE stimulus programs have been announced, they have inevitably provided support for markets.

War footing: Disregarding deficits

Given that we have very little historical context to draw on in this regard, our view is that it is time to throw away the rulebook. Economic proposals that are now 7 days old seem a little timid, compared to where we seem to be going. We are very pleased to see how quickly policymakers have recognised ‘this time it actually is different’. “We have to be willing to accept fiscal deficits on the scale of 2009,” said Adair Turner, the former head of the UK’s Financial Services Authority, in the Financial Times.

Exceptional times, mean exceptional circumstances, and economist and policy makers are warming up to radical solutions. Central banks have turned the fire hose on full blast with a range of new
asset purchase programs, the question then it how to finance them. Under normal circumstances, a government would borrow to finance the range of measures being implemented. However, there is another means – a means whereby it simply prints money to finance it’s own spending.

This has been referred to as ‘monetary finance’ but more colloquially, has been referred to as ‘helicopter money’. In essence, this trying to be more surgical about transferring monies to the private sector, to reach the real economy, in a way that quantitative easing measures perhaps haven’t so far. It’s a simple premise at heart, put money directly into consumers hands who may have lost their jobs – a very targeted economic backstop.

Until now, there have been disciplines and controls in central banking , but now we are on a war footing, past taboos are being, and will continue to be broken. This has been very well demonstrated this weekend just past when Germany, the last bastion of fiscal discipline has announced a 368BN EUR program which will buy all sort of assets, including taking equity positions in companies where necessary. They have taken the view, that potentially inflationary consequences further down the line are very much a consequence worth taking on at this point in time.

WHAT IS ‘HELICOPTER MONEY’?

Inspired by the example of Hong Kong, (cash handouts of HK$10,000 to all permanent residents), US, UK and European economists and politicians are considering something similar.

In the past few days, policymakers have put forwards a raft of bold and substantial measures to tackle COVID-19 head on:

• Germany has set out it will underwrite businesses by way of loans and credit guarantees
provided with a 550bn EUR ‘bazooka’ to provide businesses unlimited cash.

• French premier Macron has declared war on the outbreak, publicly declaring no business in France will fall to the virus, offering 300bn EUR of state guarantees to SME’s.

• In the last few days US Senator Mitt Romney, suggested a handout of 1000 USD to every
American in the interests of increasing spending in the US economy. As of this weekend, this is now in Congress being weighed along with a 1trn USD stimulus program.

It was only weeks ago, the idea of ‘monetary finance’, or helicopter money was confined to academic circles. There has been much criticism that the quantitative easing programs globally have benefitted the few, not the many. Therefore, helicopter money seeks to address that by, in short being a direct transfer of funds from governments to consumers – an attempt to be more surgical in increasing consumer demand. We live in a world whereby trillions of dollars of stimulus have perhaps increased the prices of
certain stock market investments, but done little for ‘real economic activity’ or for that matter, create any inflation, which in moderation, can act as a lubricant to economic growth. Stimulus this time round will seek to target the consumer’s bank account directly.

As the economic impact of the COVID-19 outbreak becomes clearer in the coming weeks, the concept of helicopter money or direct handouts to the end consumer, will generate more and more headlines. Central banks have provided massive monetary stimulus in recent weeks, but lower interest rates can only do so much. What is needed to revive private consumption and global growth generally is he consumer to spend once more. Increasing fiscal stimulus measures of the magnitude required to address the economic impact of the pandemic will likely generate inflationary pressures that have been
absent without leave for so long, but that is a price worth paying and is still in the middle distance yet.

THE SILVER LINING

China is recovering. In fact, in conversations we have with our counterparts in South East Asia, many factories are running at full tilt 24/7 already. Regardless of whether many will question its data, last week Starbucks opened all of its coffee shops once more. That is ‘hard data’ that can’t be manipulated. China does benefit from an ability to govern and mandate citizen behaviour in a more authoritarian manner than perhaps more Western economies do. But we think the penny has dropped now globally – China went on lockdown, and extended the China Lunar holidays – and after a giant collective effort,
they are seeing the fruits of those actions. Within 40 days of lockdown, congestion started to pick up once more and daily life adopted a more normalised (and outside) reality. This weekend, Chinese citizens across the countries are outside once more, spending time in parks.

ASSET ALLOCATION CONSIDERATIONS

The speed of the correction in markets hasn’t been seen before – this seems to be outpacing 1929 even. The FTSE 100 has fallen 34% from 7550 in February to approximately 4985 as we stand three weeks into March. We are seeing daily records being set.

Portfolios have not escaped unscathed, although have fared much better than the broad equity markets. Even what are considered ‘safe havens’, being government bonds have not escaped the selling as investors have sought to raise cash wherever possible. Throughout the first weeks of the sell off, we used a range of hedging techniques, such as investing in the US Dollar, gold along with positions and insurance policies that can benefit from falling markets. Admittedly, across our funds, as readings in certain indicators saw some of the extremes that were registered in 2008, we did put some cash to
work and remove some of the defensive measures we have invested into.

This was perhaps a little premature, as incredibly, some of the extreme readings we’re referring too – such as percentage falls in markets without a bounce, the level of ‘fear’ in markets, a jump in fixed income ‘stress’ indicators – have actually registered even greater extremes than those that indicated the bottom of the selling in 2008. That said in the last few days, we have seen some growing evidence of and hence improving probabilities for a sustained rally. We will look to tactically benefit from any bounce, even if short lived, before taking on a more defensive stance once more. We are actively managing the funds like we never have before, almost minute by minute. Whilst it may still be premature to make too much of, it’s clear that already the market correction has created some multi-generational buying opportunities in certain companies. We believe there are more to follow in the weeks to come – even though that will likely mean keeping powder dry for those opportunities for a little while yet.

CONCLUDING THOUGHTS AND A RALLYING CALL: ‘THE ONLY THING WE HAVE TO FEAR IS FEAR ITSELF’

Government and central bank intervention needs to be two pronged at this point. Initially, it needs to be of such a shock and awe size, so comprehensive, that investors can take comfort that there is a serious economic backstop in place and the measures are in place to help businesses survive. These measures are being unveiled. In essence, Rishi Sunak, the UK Chancellor of the Exchequer has written a blank cheque for the UK economy – in a bold move, which is actually an extraordinary’ whatever it takes approach, for any government, particularly a conservative one. This was the third emerging measure
announced in the last 10 days and should be applauded.

However, swift action also needs to go beyond stemming the tide. It needs to provide a focal point for investors to see beyond the immediate challenges and recognise a further stimulus to an enduring recovery is on the horizon. Michael Bloomberg, amongst others, has called for the largest public investment in infrastructure in generations.

Such infrastructure investment program has been seen before – more importantly, has been successful before. In 1933, President Franklin D Roosevelt – himself diagnosed with polio, which was subject to its own epidemic, declared ‘The only thing we have to fear is fear itself’. He was referring broadly to a nameless fear that can lead to paralysis by analysis, meaning retreat rather than advance. Massive infrastructure spend was a central plank in the economic recovery that followed 1933. We expect that such announcements globally can not only be a foundation upon which investors can become more positive, and give them reason to expect a government spend led recovery in the coming months – but
there is the welcome benefit that it would allow countries globally to build new, energy efficient and economically enabling infrastructure for the decades to come.

To find out more about the ARIA’s Fund Management Services please email andrew.sheena@ariacm.com or call +971 (0) 4 325 2800.

ARIA Capital Management is a trading name of Absolute Return Investment Advisers (ARIA) Limited. Office: Building 2, Ground Floor, Guildford Business Park, Guildford, GU2 8XG. Absolute Return Investment Advisers (ARIA) Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
 

DISCLAIMER

The information on this site is issued by ARIA CAPITAL MANAGEMENT. ‘ARIA’ and ‘ARIA CAPITAL MANAGEMENT’ are TRADING NAMES of ABSOLUTE RETURN INVESTMENT ADVISERS (ARIA) Limited, who are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in the UK, with Firm Reference number 527557. A Limited Company registered in England and Wales No: 7091239. Contact Address: Ground Floor, 2 Bell Court, Leapale Lane, Guildford GU1 4LY. Telephone: +44 (0)203 137 3840 The information on this site is directed only at persons or entities in any jurisdiction or country where such access to information contained herein and use thereof is not contrary to local law or regulation. In particular, the information on this site is not directed at any person in the United States and this site is not intended to be used by any person in the United States. Accordingly, all persons who access this site are required to inform themselves of and to comply with any such restrictions. Sales Restrictions United Kingdom: there are funds referred to on this site, which are not recognised collective investment schemes for the purposes of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 of the United Kingdom (the 'Act'). The promotion of such investment funds and the distribution of offering materials in relation to such funds in the United Kingdom are accordingly restricted by law. The information contained on the restricted part of this site (the 'Intermediary Centre') is directed only at persons to whom such investment funds may lawfully be promoted by a person authorised under the Act (an 'authorised person') by virtue of Section 238(5) of the Act and Chapter 4 (part 12) of the FCA New Conduct of Business Sourcebook. Investors in the investment funds referred to in the Restricted Area will not benefit from the rules and regulations made under the Act for the protection of investors, nor from the Financial Services Compensation Scheme. Shares in the investment funds referred to in the Intermediary Centre are not dealt in or on a recognised or designated investment exchange for the purposes of the Act, nor is there a market maker in such shares, and it may therefore be difficult for an investor to dispose of his shares otherwise than by way of redemption. General: it may be illegal to access or download the information contained in this site in certain countries and ARIA disclaims all responsibility if you access or download any information from this site in breach of any law or regulation of the country in which you are residing. Access to the Intermediary Centre requires possession of a valid password and no other person should attempt to gain access to it. An application for shares in the investment funds referred to on this site should only be made having read fully the relevant prospectus and other information contained on this site. It is your responsibility to use such documentation and by making an application you will be deemed to represent that you have read such applicable documentation and agree to be bound by its contents. No Advice The information on this site is provided solely on the basis that you make your own investment decisions and does not constitute a personal recommendation or investment advice. Should you have any queries about the investment funds or services referred to on this site, you should contact your financial adviser. Taxation will depend on an individual financial circumstances and the country of residence. Please seek professional advice in relation to any taxation issues which may arise from your interest in investment funds or services referred to on this site. Risk Factors Past performance may not be repeated and should not be seen as a guide to future performance. The value of investments and the income from them may go down as well as up and investors may not get back the amount originally invested. Because of this, you are not certain to make a profit on your investments and you may lose money. Exchange rates may cause the value of overseas investments and the income arising from them to rise or fall. The levels and bases of and reliefs from taxation may change. Any tax reliefs referred to are those currently available and their value depends on the circumstances of the individual investor. Investors should consult their own tax adviser in order to understand any applicable tax consequences. ARIA has taken every step to ensure the accuracy of the information and statistics on this site and within its literature but cannot accept any liability for errors or any direct or consequential loss arising from the use of this document or its contents. Before taking any action you should consult your financial adviser as to the suitability to you of any investments or services mentioned on this site or within any literature available on this site. Accuracy of Information The information contained on this site (including any expression of opinion or forecast) has been obtained from, or is based on, sources believed by ARIA to be reliable, but is not guaranteed as to its accuracy or completeness. Such information is provided without obligation on the part of ARIA and its associated companies and on the understanding that any person who acts upon it or changes his investment position in reliance on it does so entirely at his own risk. The information contained on this site does not constitute an offer to buy or sell or an invitation to make an offer to buy or sell shares in any investment funds referred to herein. Information posted on this site is current only as at the date it is first posted and may no longer be true or complete when viewed by you. All information contained on this site may be changed or amended without prior notice although ARIA does not guarantee to update this site regularly. No Liability No representation, warranty or undertaking is given as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained on this site by ARIA or any of its associated companies and no liability is accepted by such persons for the accuracy or completeness of such information. In no event will ARIA or any of its associated companies be liable to any person for any direct, indirect, special or consequential damages arising out of any use of the information contained on this site, or on any other hyper-linked site, including, without limitation, any lost profits, business interruption, loss of programs or data on your equipment, or otherwise, even if ARIA is expressly advised of the possibility or likelihood of such damages. This does not exclude or restrict any duty or liability that ARIA has to its customers under the regulatory system in the United Kingdom. You should be aware that the Internet is not a completely reliable transmission medium. ARIA does not accept any liability for any data transmission errors such as data loss or damage or alteration of any kind, including, but not limited to any direct, indirect or consequential damage, arising out of the use of the products or services referred to herein. This does not exclude or restrict any duty or liability that ARIA has to its customers under the regulatory system in the United Kingdom. Indemnity You agree to indemnify, defend, and hold harmless ARIA, its affiliates and licensors, and the officers, partners, employees, and agents of ARIA and its affiliates and licensors, from and against any and all claims, liabilities, damages, losses, or expenses, including legal fees and costs, arising out of or in any way connected with your access to or use of this site or any literature available on this site. Material Interest ARIA and its partners, officers and/or employees may have holdings in the investment funds referred to on this site and may otherwise be interested in transactions that you effect in those funds. Linked Websites This site may be linked to third party websites or contain information provided by third parties. ARIA does not make any representation as to the accuracy or completeness of such websites or information, has not and will not review or update such websites or information, and cautions browsers that any use made of such websites or information is at their own risk. ARIA does not accept any liability arising out of the information contained on any linked website or information on this site provided by a third party and the use of such sites and information is at your own risk. This does not exclude or restrict any duty or liability that ARIA has to its customers under the regulatory system in the United Kingdom. Copyright, Trademarks and Other Rights Copyright, trademarks, database rights, patents and all similar rights in this site and the information contained in it are owned by ARIA, its licensors or relevant third party content providers. You may use the information on this site and reproduce it in hard copy for your personal reference only. Such information may not otherwise be reproduced, distributed or transmitted to any other person or incorporated in any way into another database, document or other materials. Nothing on this site should be considered as granting any licence or right under any trademark of ARIA or any third party. Privacy and Cookies Please refer to ARIA’s Privacy Policy for full details. FRC Stewardship Code The Stewardship Code (“the Code”), which has been published by the Financial Reporting Council, sets out principles for institutional investors in relation to engagement with the companies in which they have invested. The FCA’s regulations oblige any firm which manages investments for institutional clients to publicly disclose the nature of its commitment to the Code, or where it does not commit to the Code its alternative approach. ARIA’s investment strategy, notwithstanding that this may vary depending on the mandate received from the client, is in general such that the firm does not consider it to be appropriate for it to engage directly with companies in which it invests. The scale on which the firm manages investments for institutional clients is such that engagement would not be cost-effective and appropriate for those clients. The firm does not consider that those institutional clients for whom it manages investments expect engagement.
DISCLAIMER